Categories: Sports

The Cardinals Won’t Make a Big Splash – A Deadline Retrospective

It’s hard to tell right now if the Cardinals will be buyers or sellers over the next couple of days; the team sits at .500 while they are currently playing, but they are 7-3 in their last 10. They have some big holes on this roster, and adding a rental or 2 might not make them a World Series contender.

Judging by the history of the team, it doesn’t appear they would make a splash anyway. Here are all of the deadline deals that John Mozeliak has made:

The biggest deal they made was for Holliday. The most recent “big deal” would probably be the Craig/Kelly for Lackey deal. The “win now” deal would be Dotel/Jackson from 2011 that led to a World Series Championship.

More recently, the team has been “shifting assets”. They got rid of Pham because he was a “cancer”, Voit because they had just extended Carpenter (and would end up with Paul Goldschmidt), and Mercado because they had a glut of outfielders and needed to clear a 40-man spot (which would also happen to Adolis Garcia and Randy Arozarena down the line). At least these deal did bring back decent players that are impacting the roster now – Gallegos, Cabrera, J Williams.

The most recent deal was sending out Gyorko’s contract while taking on an injured player and a low level minor leaguer.

I think we’ll see more of these types of moves in the next few days. The Cardinals won’t want to give up Nolan Gorman, Matthew Liberatore, or Ivan Herrera for a rental. They also don’t have the depth to get a guy under club control. We’ll see them pick up some more low hanging fruit, like an inning eater for the rotation (a la Masterson) and a bullpen arm or 2 (a la Duke and Broxton). These are needs and will allow the team to say they did something.

They won’t get a Trevor Story, a Max Scherzer, or a Craig Kimbrel. I can’t say that I blame them either; the team would need all 3 to be a true contender. Unfortunately the weakening farm system would be wiped bare and the guys that are close to making an impact are worth too much in the next 2 years to waste on guys that could walk after the season.

The best course of action is to wait until the off-season; they’ll have a lot of money coming off the books and players like Story and Scherzer will be available as free agents.

Eugene Tierney

Recent Posts

MiLB Announces May 2026 Players of the Month

Minor League Baseball™ (MiLB™) announced the Player and Pitcher of the Month Award winners for…

2 days ago

Cardinals Name Won-Bin Cho And Max Rajcic Players of the Month for May 2026

The St. Louis Cardinals today announced their selections for Minor League Player and Pitcher of…

2 days ago

Bad Brains’ DARRYL JENIFER Announces New Jazz-Fusion ‘The Weather Channel’

Darryl Jenifer — bassist and founding member of the legendary hardcore innovators Bad Brains — returns with The Weather…

2 weeks ago

Creative Marketing Strategies to Grow Your Brewery Audience and Loyalty

For local brewery owners and taproom managers, the toughest part often isn’t the beer, it’s…

2 weeks ago

THIS IS ME BREATHING Unveil New Single “Return To None” Ahead of New Album

Missouri deathcore crushers This Is Me Breathing continue their relentless march toward the release of their upcoming…

2 weeks ago

2026 Busch Stadium Homestand Highlights #6

The Cardinals return to Busch Stadium to begin the first of a 9-game homestand w/…

2 weeks ago

This website uses cookies.